What was Onans sin? - Biblical Hermeneutics Stack Exchange Onan's sin was entirely related to his refusal to perform his levirate duty Quickly about the other three: Coitus interruptus is not masturbation It is a (very unreliable) method of birth control Onan was attempting not to get Tamar pregnant because he did not want to provide an heir for his deceased older brother It was not "theft of Tamar
Judahs sons Er Onan were killed by God for their sins, and yet . . . Judah, the father of Er Onan, apparently was the "brotherhood" ring leader, who suggested that Joseph be sold to the Midianites, unbeknownst to Rueben - firstborn of the 4 brethren, to Jacob Leah, that included Simeon, Levi and Judah - who had sought to free Joseph from the pit that all the brothers, (by whichever wife maidservant of Jacob
Why did God punish Cain and Onan so differently? Thus Onan, by practicing birth control with Tamar, was a threat to the seed, that is the Promise, whereas Judah, by sleeping with a prostitute, was a friend of the Promise Thus one was put to death and the other was honored, even though by human standards of justice Judah's crime was worse than Onan's
The problem of the ages of Judahs sons and grandson Genesis 38:1 and the rest of the chapter tells us the story of Judah and his children According to the account, after the sale of Joseph to the Midianites, Judah, possibly driven by remorse, moves away from his brothers and marries with a Canaanite She later becomes pregnant, and bears him three children: Er, Onan and Shelah
Could there be a chronological discord in Genesis 37, 38 39? He points out that Judah's second son Onan had to have reached childbearing age, which he assumes must be at least 12 years old (plus at least a year and a half or so for the pregnancies of Er and Onan), then there was the unspecified time period where Tamar lived in her father's house (38:11-12), then there is the time for Tamar to become
genesis - What made Er evil in the sight of the Lord? - Biblical . . . Er and Onan indulged in unnatural intercourse An objection was raised: During all the twenty-four months one may thresh within and winnow without; these are the words of R Eliezer The others said to him: Such actions are only like the practice of Er and Onan!
genesis - Who did Shelah (Judahs son) marry? - Biblical Hermeneutics . . . Because Numbers 26:20 mentions descendants of Shelah, Judah's son, so this makes me wonder if he did eventually marry Tamar, since usually a deceased man who was childless would have his brother marry his wife to carry on the family line, as Onan did after Er died
Why did Tamar sleep with her father-in-law? (Genesis 38:13-18) It says in Genesis 38:13-18 NKJV 13 And it was told Tamar, saying, “Look, your father-in-law is going up to Timnah to shear his sheep ” 14 So she took off her widow’s garments, covered herself with a veil and wrapped herself, and sat in an open place which was on the way to Timnah; for she saw that Shelah was grown, and she was not given to him as a wife
genesis - Why is Tamar more righteous than Judah? - Biblical . . . In accordance with this law, Tamar is then given by Judah to Onan to bear a son to his deceased brother This law was so binding that when Onan refused to fulfill this obligation he incurred the wrath of God and God slew him as well Judah told Tamar to remain in her father's house until Shelah grew up and he would give her to him
Why is Zerah mentioned in Matthews genealogy? David's Genealogy Judah's sons Jacob's sons 1 Abraham 1 Er 1 Rueben 2 Isaac 2 Onan 2 Simeon 3 Jacob 3 Shelah 3 Levi 4 Judah 4 Zerah (Tamar) 4 Judah 5 Perez (Tamar) 5 Perez (Tamar) 5 Dan (Bilhah) By including Zerah and Tamar, Matthew has presented three genealogic sequences which arrive at a 5 th son from a mother who was not a wife of the father