Is sortition a good idea? : r PoliticalScience - Reddit Sortition is a concept that’s been thrown around quite a bit (most recently here in Australia) I’d say one of the major issues with it is the fact that a majority of individuals selected wouldn’t possess many of the professional skills that most elected representatives currently do, such as legal and procedural knowledge, relationships with their constituents, etc A similar critique
Does anyone prefer sortition to direct democracy and if so, why? Sortition solves this problem through the lottery, so that only a small fraction of the whole needs to make decisions Moreover, sortition compensates the legislatures, so that people are paid for their labor Direct democracy in contrast demands unpaid, unrewarded, voluntary labor The results are therefore amateurish
Why randomly choosing people to serve in government may be the . . . - Reddit So I'm a huge advocate of something known as sortition, where people are randomly selected to serve in a legislature Unfortunately the typical gut reaction against sortition is bewilderment and skepticism How could we possibly trust ignorant, stupid, normal people to become our leaders?
Why randomly selecting people to serve in government is . . . - Reddit I'm a huge advocate of something known as sortition, where people are randomly selected to serve in a legislature Unfortunately the typical gut reaction against sortition is bewilderment and skepticism How could we possibly trust ignorant, normal people to become our leaders?
Randomly choosing people to serve in government - sortition - may be . . . Sortition was also used in combination with elections for the selection of leadership in Renaissance-era Italian City States such as a Venice and Florence Examples of sortition have also been documented to be used in Indian tribes In these tribes, sortition results in an egalitarian government where power is shared
Athenian Sortition is not suitable for Modern Democracies These famously included sortition, a mechanism by which citizens were randomly selected to serve in government for a period typically of 1 year When sortition is discussed in a modern context, it is usually thought of as a supplement (or occasionally replacement) for representative systems, and it is in that context I will address the system
what is the BEST argument AGAINST sortition? : r Sortition - Reddit Sortition is untested, and it may be better to stick with the system that has been working, for fear of creating some sort of dictatorship Sortition may also create easily manipulated politicians for companies, organizations, and other enterprises
What would be the best option here? Never played a republic . . . - Reddit What exactly is sortition? Sorry if it's a dumb question, I've played over a dozen eu4 games but never a republic before Reply reply HighestOfLords • Basically you get 3 options to pick but it costs traditon to select specific or recelect or you can let rng pick but picks arent 1 1 4 type but regular picks You could get 3 3 4s 541s but its
CMV: Sortition is a valid form of government that would work . . . - Reddit CMV: Sortition is a valid form of government that would work better then most systems currently in place I believe that Sortition would be a great form of government compared to current systems such Presidential or Parliamentary