word choice - Ungrammatical or Grammatically Incorrect - English . . . Gramatical is a term used to describe a phrase or word that follows the rules of grammar To say something is grammatically incorrect would be like saying it is “right wrong” or “correct incorrect” The term ungrammatical, on the other hand, suggests the phrase word is not grammatical or does not follow the rules of grammar
grammar - What differences and relationships are there between . . . They do not explicitly state this in the quoted text, but it is possible to be ungrammatical in any of the styles of standard English The authors also distinguish non-standard from standard, which they identify as dialects What may be typical of a dialect may be ungrammatical in standard English Here's what I take as the summary:
What exactly does it mean to say something is grammatical? So what is judged to be grammatical at one point in time may be judged to be marginal, or outright ungrammatical, a hundred years later, say The number of speakers who follow the rule has dwindled and the number of people who violate it has grown
grammaticality - What is ungrammatical about thats them? - English . . . But in dialog, whatever people say is what is written, and the reading's all the better for that "I declared in an ungrammatical whisper" is merely Christie's successful attempt to say "I said" in an unusual and more interesting way than "I whispered" –
grammaticality - Is this sentence ungrammatical? She wrote a book . . . @CayceEvans It is difficult to categorically proclaim something is or is not grammatical when acceptability varies so much across native speakers as this does If it sounds ungrammatical to you, who are clearly a native speaker, then that data point cannot be discarded no matter what else you may discover grammar books saying about it –
Why is the deletion ungrammatical in I like the girl [who is] the . . . Note that in the case of your first sentence, the removing could change how the sentence gets understood Presented as here outside any context, the version without who was is likely to be interpreted to mean that the speaker was happy to see that the child was speaking to Mr
grammar - Are these ungrammatical sentences? - English Language Usage . . . Yes, the first sentence and the second are ungrammatical What is the context of the first one? Are you supposed to restructure it? Or is it some sort of "fill in the blank'? The second sentence: "David had a stick with which to scare his _____" is missing an object An example would be: dog, brother, attacker, etc
grammaticality - English Language Usage Stack Exchange the first two are ungrammatical because of the tense and temporal aspect of the verbs The other two are alright, because the semantics are broader and allow for different aspects Or because colloquial speech tends to reduction
Is Whom did you give the book? ungrammatical? Despite the rarity, I have found conflicting statements from grammar experts about whether it is definitely ungrammatical (which may reflect a similar variance in native speakers' intuitions ) All of them agree that is is at the very least infelicitous for many speakers As ChongDogMillionare said, the fact that we can say You gave him the book